top of page

The Elephant in the Room

A Missouri court dropped over a $1 billion bomb on the NAR for commission disput.

What does this mean for California?

Well at this moment nothing. BUT if the California Association of Realtors does have to respond to this this will upend the buyer's agent compensation. Buyers will have to pay their buyer's agent commissions, or buyers go unrepresented or buyers can be represented solely by the seller's agent. I personally have done dual agency and it is a very slippery slope when representing both the buyer and seller.

First, let's look at what each type of agent does. Let's remember most of the work for the buyer's agent and sellers agent is done without ever seeing any compensation.

Seller's Agent Responsibilities: A seller's agent, also known as a listing agent, is a real estate professional who represents the seller in a property transaction. Their role involves several key responsibilities aimed at ensuring the seller's interests are well-represented and that the property is sold in a timely manner and for the best possible price. Here’s an overview of the typical duties of a seller's agent:

  1. Market Analysis: The agent will conduct a comparative market analysis (CMA) to determine a competitive selling price for the property based on current market conditions and comparable homes that have sold nearby.

  2. Listing the Property: They will list the property for sale, which includes putting it on the Multiple Listing Service (MLS), where it can be seen by agents representing potential buyers.

  3. Marketing: The agent will market the property through various channels, including online listings, social media, print advertising, open houses, and networking with other real estate professionals to attract potential buyers.

  4. Staging and Presentation: They often advise on staging the home to make it more appealing. This can include suggesting and arranging for professional staging services, decluttering, and making repairs or improvements that will enhance the property's attractiveness.

  5. Negotiation: When offers are received, the seller's agent will negotiate with potential buyers or their agents on behalf of the seller to achieve the best price and terms.

  6. Legal and Regulatory Compliance: They ensure that all disclosures required by law are made to potential buyers, such as known defects or material facts about the property.

  7. Communication: The agent maintains communication with the seller, providing updates on the market situation, feedback from showings, and guidance through each step of the selling process.

  8. Transaction Management: Once an offer is accepted, the seller's agent will manage the transaction process, coordinating with escrow companies, title companies, inspectors, appraisers, and the buyer's agent to ensure all necessary paperwork and legal steps are completed leading up to the closing.

  9. Problem Solving: If issues arise during the sale process, such as inspection problems, the seller's agent will work to resolve these issues by negotiating repairs or concessions and keeping the transaction on track.

  10. Closing: The seller's agent will assist in the closing process, ensuring that all the seller's obligations have been met, that the closing goes smoothly and that the seller understands all the documents they are signing.

In summary, the seller's agent plays a crucial role in preparing, marketing, and selling a property, while acting as the seller's advocate to maximize the sale price and ensure a smooth transaction process. They provide expert advice, and market insight, and handle the complex aspects of the real estate selling process.

Buyer's Agent Responsibilities: A buyer's agent, also known as a purchasing agent, is a licensed real estate professional who represents the interests of the buyer in a real estate transaction. Here are the primary duties and services a buyer's agent typically provides:

  1. Understanding Buyer Needs: The agent starts by interviewing the buyer to understand their needs, preferences, budget, and timeline. This helps to target the search and find suitable properties efficiently.

  2. Property Search: The agent uses various resources, relationships with other local agents, off market listings of their own, Multiple Listing Service (MLS), to find properties that match the buyer's criteria and arrange for showings of those properties.

  3. Market Education: The buyer's agent educates the buyer on current market conditions, the buying process, and what they can expect in their price range and desired location.

  4. Property Evaluation: The agent assists the buyer in evaluating the pros and cons of different properties, including location, condition, size, and amenities.

  5. Pricing and Value Assessment: They provide the buyer with comparative market analyses (CMAs) for selected properties to help determine a fair offer price.

  6. Making an Offer: Once the buyer decides on a property, the agent helps to draft an offer to purchase and advises on terms and contingencies.

  7. Negotiation: The buyer's agent negotiates on behalf of the buyer with the seller or the seller's agent to get the best possible price and terms.

  8. Inspections and Due Diligence: They coordinate property inspections and advise the buyer on how to handle any issues that may arise from the inspections.

  9. Financing Assistance: Although not financial advisors, buyer's agents can help buyers understand their financing options and may refer them to mortgage professionals.

  10. Problem Solving: If any problems are encountered during the buying process, such as issues with the home inspection or financing hurdles, the agent works to resolve them.

  11. Legal and Paperwork: The agent ensures that all necessary legal documents are in order and that the buyer understands the details of the contract and closing process.

  12. Closing: The buyer's agent will accompany the buyer to the closing, making sure that all the buyer's interests are protected and that any agreed-upon repairs or other conditions are completed prior to finalizing the sale.

  13. Post-Sale Follow-Up: They often assist with post-closing issues, including the transfer of utilities, and may help the buyer find local contractors for renovations or repairs.

A buyer's agent's role is to be the buyer's advocate, providing them with advice and guidance throughout the home-buying process, representing their interests exclusively, and helping them make informed decisions. This representation can help buyers save time and money, as well as avoid the potential pitfalls of the home-buying process.

Let's go back to the law suit and how it could potentially affect the real estate market in California...

A general assessment of how certain types of antitrust litigation or regulatory action against the National Association of Realtors (NAR) could potentially affect the real estate market in California.

If the case involves antitrust concerns, such as commission structures or MLS practices:

Potential Effects in California:

1. Commission Changes: If the case leads to a ruling that alters how commissions are structured or disclosed, California real estate agents and brokers might need to adjust their business models. For instance, sellers might not be required to pay the buyer's agent commission, which could lower overall transaction costs.

2. Increased Competition: California's market could see an increase in competition among real estate agents and brokers as new models of service and pricing emerge, possibly driven by technology companies and new online platforms.

3. Greater Transparency: There might be an increase in transparency in real estate transactions, particularly regarding commission rates and agent duties, which could benefit consumers.

4. Access to MLS Listings: Changes in MLS policies could make it easier for non-traditional real estate service providers to operate in California, potentially providing consumers with more options for listing and viewing properties.

5. Legal and Regulatory Adjustments: Real estate professionals in California may need to navigate new legal and regulatory requirements, which could complicate the buying and selling process temporarily as the industry adjusts.

6. Market Dynamics: The overall dynamics of the California real estate market could shift. If costs to sellers decrease due to lower commission fees, it could affect the pricing and affordability of homes.

7. Consumer Behavior: Consumers in California could benefit from a more diverse market with different types of real estate services, possibly at different price points, giving them more choice in how they buy or sell homes.

Potential Challenges in California:

1. Uncertainty for Agents and Brokers: Real estate professionals might face uncertainty and anxiety about their future income and the sustainability of their current business practices.

2. Adjustment Period: The industry may go through an adjustment period with confusion or resistance from existing professionals accustomed to traditional practices.

3. Legal Compliance: Ensuring compliance with any new legal precedents or regulations could require legal consultation and training, which could be costly and time-consuming.

4. Market Disruption: In the short term, the market might experience some disruption as both buyers and sellers adjust to new practices and pricing models.

5. Impact on Service Levels: There's a possibility that changes in commission structures could impact the level of service provided by agents if they are earning less per transaction.

Remember, the actual impact would depend on the specifics of the case, the final ruling, and how that ruling changes the practices of real estate professionals and the expectations of buyers and sellers. As with any regulatory change, there would likely be a period of adjustment as all stakeholders in the California real estate market adapt to the new landscape.

Whew, that was a lot to unpack but important as we watch how this will all affect California.


bottom of page